Menu

The story

Each try was a brand-new AI that learned by trial and error. Most of them fell. Here is what went wrong, and what finally worked.

  1. ✕Try 1 falls
  2. ↻Falling costs more, and it scores
  3. ✕Try 8 walks backwards
  4. ✕A 2.6° knee bug
  5. ✕The restart goes wrong
  6. ✓Try 36 walks
  7. ✓Football school
  8. ✓Getting up is its own skill
  9. ✓Eight teams, eight coaches
  1. ✕ Try 1 falls

    Each try was a brand-new AI that had never stood up. It earns points for what we want and loses points for what we don’t, then tries again, millions of times. The first one falls over.

  2. ↻ Falling costs more, and it scores

    Our first athlete, Bolt, kicked the ball and fell. It was chasing points: moving the ball paid, and falling cost almost nothing. So we made falling cost more, and it scored. Then it got stuck, dribbling for points instead of shooting.

  3. ✕ Try 8 walks backwards

    Try 8 learned to walk, but backwards. Nothing in its points ever paid for facing where it was going, so it never did. Try 24 was paid to face its way and walked forwards at last, and two tries later Bolt scored in 80% of its tests.

  4. ✕ A 2.6° knee bug

    Then we looked closely at Bolt’s legs. Its knees could bend 2.6 degrees, when they were meant to bend 150. A units bug read radians as degrees, so every AI so far had walked on stiff legs. We fixed the body and started over.

  5. ✕ The restart goes wrong

    With working knees, speed paid, so it leapt and flipped. Paid for feet taking turns, it skipped. Told to mirror its legs, it still skipped, and with four times the push, the same. Paid for when its feet landed, it pattered. Then a stiff peg leg: one good leg still earned most of the pay.

  6. ✓ Try 36 walks

    Try 36 was a new AI with every fix from its first step. After 30 minutes of training it took real steps, and after four and a half hours it could turn around and stop. Every player in the league comes from this one.

  7. ✓ Football school

    Four a side, and every player has the same brain. They learned by playing each other, match after match, falling all around and getting back up. After 19 hours came the brain all eight teams start from.

  8. ✓ Getting up is its own skill

    A fallen player needs a separate brain to get up. Untrained, it can’t. Forty-nine minutes of training later, it’s up, and every player in the league uses it.

  9. ✓ Eight teams, eight coaches

    Then each team got a coach with its own plan: all-out attack, park the bus, go long, defend first, press high, play it wide, play by the book, or go through the middle. Then the league begins.